Connecting Research To Reality: Our Community Presentation in Connellsville

We just gave our community presentation in Connellsville, and it’s crazy to think we’re coming up on the end of the project! This past Friday, after spending a while doing all this research and trying to translate it in an effective yet relevant way for our business owners, we returned to Fayette County for a display of our progress. Even better, we enjoyed another half day in the community talking to locals over lunch, and I even had a very interesting opportunity to discuss the importance of voting with one business owner (not my own) and the local senator! The day ended with some team photos and some brief playing with a giant chess board, and I went home feeling satisfied with our performance but also anticipating the next steps.

My Experience & Learnings Our Presentation 

    Going into this week, I knew we had all our data ready, but I was initially unsure about whether we could communicate the key points easily with such a number-heavy deliverable. This was especially true because we’d been hearing amongst some of the business owners that not everyone completely understood the context of our project, the STEPP Forward program, or even why they needed all this macro-level data. That said, I’m proud of the way we approached that challenge, and we started by having each group member focus on writing bullet points for slides they already did the research on. This ensured we kept the people who had the most knowledge of individual parts of our research talking about what they know, allowing our presentation to be less about reading slides and more about us conveying authority on the subject matter, especially if the community had questions later. For the other pieces, we really tried to think about what we’d talked about in class regarding understanding our audience and ended up using parts of the presentation outline Bryan presented to us. The skeleton acted as a good starting point to ensure we were hitting all the points we needed to address for our clients, and then we were able to use our actual research, plus our understanding of the audience and the logical flow of the information, to help guide decisions on what else we might want to add or remove from the original agenda.

    The practice run we did in class, along with the detailed feedback we received, was particularly helpful in refining the outcome, and I definitely learned a lot that assisted us in delivering our final presentation successfully. We made sure to hold a separate team meeting to go through our slides, make edits, and practice our presentation more than just the once before we visited, which I definitely think was a good move we will be repeating for DC. This presentation was also a good reminder that consulting means constantly learning and adapting, and even if I’ve done the GSL program, I still am never going to be done improving, nor is the client always going to need the same communication approach, so it was a good exercise to get the critical feedback from our professors and use it to make our presentation better. We really tried to contextualize the complex structure of the project with all the different partners involved and why our part of the research was important for the clients to formulate their business plans, and I think it ended up going very well overall. Personally, I was presenting a data-heavy national economic slide, so I really tried to take to heart the notes we got about knowing the material well enough to not read the slide and elaborate on some of the points. I also made sure to look around the audience and talk with my hands while making my points, and I think it was my best run-through. As we discussed in the Ethics in Project Management reading, we wouldn’t have wanted to “lie by clutter” in our client presentation, so as a team we made a combined effort to be not just honest about our data but also deliberately clear about our meaning by getting to the point and keeping it relevant plus engaging. One lesson I did want to note for DC was not having too much shuffling around for presenters, since our large group plus a small screen was a bit complicated, especially with people doing a second slide later in the presentation. We talked about assigning our DC presenter order based on having each person do their part in one continuous motion and then switching smoothly to avoid repeating that at the conference, and given our time crunch, it will be extra important to be in sync about transitions.

    Summary of Final Deliverables & Their Value

      Our final deliverable for the project will be our individual research reports customized for each business owner. While we did write a joint part of the report with all the shared secondary research, the plan was always to keep that section the same and then include specific research for our unique clients’ industry and specific business separately to be sent to each program participant. This will be valuable to the community because each client will get not just the national, state, and local level of context around the general economic and demographic environment for local business owners, but the format also allows us to go deeper into things like competitor analysis, whether the market is too saturated, and whether the business idea or expansion plan is viable under current conditions. The addition of any extra, particular research clients wanted help with also allows us to make sure everything we did is super relevant to what they are actually doing. All this put together will give them a large amount of secondary research already handled, so they can combine it with insights from their primary research and use it directly in their comprehensive business plans in less time, increasing their capacity to focus on the other pieces they’ll need to ultimately apply for the micro-grant within the deadline. And this will also be helpful to the greater community overall because local businesses succeeding will lead to more economic growth that stays in the county, and these benefits will be felt by even non-business owners, such as if these clients might end up hiring more locals for jobs if they get the capital to do that expansion or open that storefront. 

      What Recommendation I’d Instantly Implement & Why

      If I could instantly guarantee one of the recommendations we make to all our clients was implemented, it would probably be the piece where we tell them to build off our research and not make any decisions solely on our findings. No matter which industry or business we personally worked on, our entire class knows that the part we contributed to the creation of these business plans was only secondary data. Even for those of us who actually live in the area, none of us actually have the full understanding of whether a business is viable without the primary research and seeing what the rest of the community actually thought about the business ideas. I could point to the economic trends and say, “Your industry is trending down in terms of GDP growth, and there are too many similar businesses in the area already,” but then you survey the people who actually make the purchasing decisions, and they say, “We have been waiting for a business with this specific focus in the area for a while, and I’d absolutely go there.” Unfortunately, since the project is complex and we are working with business owners with varying understanding of how to run a business successfully, there are some who may already have a well-run business and understand you can’t go in without all the information, while for others the classes they took may be their first steps into understanding how to do market research and determine viability. Because of this, if I could make sure every single business owner gets all the research they need completed on time and submits a full business plan for the grant application, that would be amazing. Though unfortunately I can’t necessarily control how these participants end up using our work or if they actually apply, I can make sure we are communicating the importance of following through on the rest of the business plan when writing these final reports for our clients, and hopefully we do end up with more businesses successfully getting some grant money at the end.

      Recommended Next Steps For Clients, Community, & Future Students

        In terms of next steps, even though we’ve completed our research, there’s still much to be done for this project. For these business owners in particular, they still have to take what we reported and incorporate that into a cohesive, fully developed business plan with all their primary research and such. Then they actually have to go through the application process for the micro grant, and though I don’t have full details, I know that will still take time to write everything out, check it all over, and then submit before the deadline, especially for any participants with businesses already running on top of this. 

        For the community overall, they and the Fayette County Cultural Trust will have to look at what we did for this cohort and then evaluate whether this approach of having students help with secondary research was successful. Did doing this improve, in a meaningful way, the realization of the end goal, which in this case is more businesses finishing their plans and securing that grant funding? If yes, they might want to think about how to build on that success for the next cohort, especially since we won’t be running this course for another year. Maybe they will look for other pools of people who can contribute to the research, like local students, or maybe they’ll optimize the program in some other way to learn from this. Even outside of just the immediate outcomes for this cohort, the community could also use positive results as a way to attract more business owners to the next cycle of the program and encourage further growth, especially if community members see these business owners expanding or opening because they got some needed grant money.

        Lastly, for the next year of students, and the overall continued success of this ten-year partnership, my recommended next steps would include potentially following up on measuring some of the outcomes from this year’s project. Knowing whether more participants succeeded in forming their business plans is not just valuable information for the FCCT and the county, but also for the student program because future participants will need to be able to navigate that aftermath. When we first were going to visit Connellsville, I remember Bryan mentioning that we should try to work in asking about prior projects and their results when speaking to community members or the FCCT, so we could also do our part in continuing to ensure the partnership is beneficial in the long term. If something didn’t go as planned after we wrapped up one year’s project, we wouldn’t want to come back in a year and find the previous cohort’s outcomes had negatively impacted the trust in the client relationship. We’d want to stay connected and communicating with our partners so we reinforce our actual commitment, and potentially have new students look into past results to then learn from and build off that prior experience for better performance. That said, maybe the interns in the spring or even next year’s cohort could do an assessment of some kind to determine the success of this year’s project, or use a similar assessment that might be done by the FCCT to then come up with additional types of community programs that could address economic growth in the area, looking for and recommending ways to fill an unmet need from STEPP Forward. But whatever the project ends up focusing on in future years, my general recommendation to future groups will always be to actively listen to the community, maintain that trust, and leverage the knowledge of prior years to ensure future projects are even more effective. Doing these things is central to being a good student consultant for this unique program, and I hope that next year’s group will have even more success to build on with our work this fall.

        Leave a Reply